The All Blacks’ 2025 season has come to a close, and it’s time to dissect the performance of every forward Scott Robertson selected. But here’s where it gets controversial: while some players shone brightly, others left us scratching our heads, raising questions about the team’s future. Let’s dive in, starting with the standout moments and the areas that need a closer look.
Forwards: A Tale of Strengths and Surprises
The All Blacks’ forwards delivered plenty of jaw-dropping moments, particularly in the front five. New Zealand’s depth in props and locks was on full display, proving they’re far from short on talent in these positions. And this is the part most people miss: while the front five thrived, the loose forward trio faced tougher challenges, though players like Peter Lakai, Wallace Sititi, and Ardie Savea still managed to impress.
Loose Forwards: Consistency Meets Controversy
Ardie Savea remained a powerhouse, but his performance wasn’t quite as dominant as in previous years. Is this a sign of decline, or just a natural ebb in an otherwise stellar career? Despite this, he maintained a high level of play, earning a solid 8/10. Christian Lio-Willie, on the other hand, had an odd year, starting strong against France but disappearing during key tournaments. His role in Robertson’s plans remains a mystery, leaving fans wondering what’s next. Du’Plessis Kirifi finally got his Test chance but failed to stand out, while Samipeni Finau’s physical prowess wasn’t enough to overcome a frustrating season. Wallace Sititi battled injuries early on but found his rhythm by season’s end, though he didn’t quite reach his 2024 peak. Simon Parker showed promise but is still waiting for his breakthrough moment, while Dalton Papali’i’s international future looks uncertain after limited playtime.
Locks: Youth and Experience Clash
Fabian Holland was the undisputed breakout star, seamlessly transitioning into Test rugby and earning the World Rugby Breakthrough Player of the Year title. His performance was a big positive in an otherwise mixed campaign. Scott Barrett, as captain, faced criticism, and it’s fair to ask: Is the weight of leadership affecting his play? Patrick Tuipulotu’s injuries were a significant blow, while Tupou Vaa’i maintained his form despite missing the November series. Josh Lord stepped up in the absence of others, but Sam Darry struggled to make a lasting impact.
Hookers: Reliability Meets Impact
Codie Taylor, in his mid-30s, remains a cornerstone of the team, delivering consistent performances. Samisoni Taukei’aho was the perfect bench option, making a significant impact whenever he stepped onto the field. Brodie McAlister showed promise on debut but didn’t get further chances, while George Bell’s limited playtime left fans wanting more.
Props: Injuries and Impact Players
Fletcher Newell admirably filled Tyrel Lomax’s shoes, though he hasn’t yet reached the elite level. Ethan de Groot improved from 2024 but still isn’t the dominant force he once was. Is this a temporary dip, or a new normal? Ollie Norris and Pasilio Tosi showed promise, while Lomax’s injury-plagued season was a setback. George Bower provided solid cover, and Tamaiti Williams, used as an impact player, wreaked havoc in the second half of matches.
Final Thoughts: What’s Next for the All Blacks?
As Scott Robertson faces scrutiny after another underwhelming season, the question remains: Can the All Blacks reclaim their dominance, or is a major overhaul needed? With players like Holland and Williams shining, there’s hope for the future. But with veterans like Savea and Taylor aging, the team’s balance is in flux. What do you think? Are the All Blacks on the right track, or is a bold new direction required? Let’s hear your thoughts in the comments!
